Don't be an innovation watchdog
Helping over compliance.
"You didn't follow the innovation framework!"
"But the customers want what we have! We have evidence!"
"You must follow the framework, otherwise you cannot proceed!"
In this encounter between the innovation manager and the innovation team both sides are partially correct. But the organisation stands to lose more with a manager who insists on compliance with the framework, than by allowing the teams some lenience.
Over the years I have seen all kinds of innovation systems, frameworks, processes, toolboxes, and similar, employed by companies of all sizes and in a number of industries. The only thing they absolutely all share in common is that there is a difference between innovation work as written and innovation work as preformed.
That is perfectly normal. After all, innovation is rife with uncertainty, can be non-linear, and is quite sensitive to environmental conditions.
Standardising practices through frameworks, systems, and similar, is also a good practice. But innovation managers should never argue for compliance just for the sake of compliance.
We document and create these innovation standards to help the innovators, managers, and executives perform the work of innovation. Their purpose is to assist us.
Developing ideas in an established firm can be a messy process. It is rarely as clean cut as strategise, generate idea, take it through a number of funnel steps, ???, profit. People arrive with ideas they have already worked on, meaning they already have some data, evidence, and assumptions about what to do next.
The best innovation managers I worked with understand that. They do not attempt to police others, but rather actively seek how they can help them innovate better. Sometimes that includes accepting that the work of innovation might not have been performed up to a specific standard. But that presents a valuable opportunity by itself---a well functioning framework can be used to quickly determine what needs to be done right now, before the idea can proceed further.
So, if you are someone who helps others innovate in your organisation, please take the above to heart. Think "how can I help" instead of "how is this wrong" and the results will follow.
Bruno Unfiltered
Subscribe to get the latest posts delivered right to your inbox. No spam. Only Bruno.